← Soul
4

Beauty as a Way of Knowing

what argument can't reach

Art gets at things propositions can't hold. This page treats attention as the skill and beauty as the teacher. Music's transcendent side lives here — the physics of sound is MIND's problem, and it's already built.

4.1

Attention, and unselfing

Murdoch's claim that looking properly at something outside yourself is a moral act, and that beauty is the most reliable occasion for it. The theoretical spine of the page.

read

  • anchorThe Sovereignty of GoodIris Murdoch
  • On Beauty and Being JustElaine Scarry
  • Art as Therapyde Botton & Armstrong

do

Twenty minutes with one object or view, describing only what is actually there. No interpretation, no meaning, no photograph.

done when you have had the experience of forgetting yourself while looking at something.

4.2

The novel as moral equipment

Fiction as the only technology for occupying another consciousness at length. Nussbaum's argument that some knowledge is available in no other form.

read

  • anchorMiddlemarchGeorge Eliot
  • anchorAnna KareninaLeo Tolstoy
  • A Swim in a Pond in the RainGeorge Saunders
  • Love's KnowledgeMartha Nussbaum

do

Read one long novel as soul-food rather than as achievement. Hand-copy three to five passages and write why each one stopped you.

done when you have a commonplace book with something in it you'd be embarrassed to explain.

4.3

Poetry, carried

The compressed form. Rilke on living the questions; Oliver on paying attention as the beginning of devotion. Poetry is the one art you can carry around inside you.

read

do

Memorise one short poem. Carry it. Say it to yourself somewhere inconvenient.

done when you have a poem available to you without a phone.

4.4

Music, and the Dionysian

Nietzsche's Dionysian — the art that dissolves the individual rather than pleasing him. Deep listening as a practice rather than a background activity.

read

  • anchorThe Birth of TragedyFriedrich Nietzsche
  • Deep ListeningPauline Oliveros
  • MusicophiliaOliver Sacks

do

One piece, in the dark, no screen, full length, following a single instrument the whole way through. Two minutes of silence afterwards before you speak or move.

done when you have listened to something all the way through without doing anything else.

4.5

Awe

Keltner's work on the emotion that reliably shrinks the self — and the finding that it is available on an ordinary walk rather than only at the Grand Canyon.

read

  • anchorAweDacher Keltner
  • Braiding SweetgrassRobin Wall Kimmerer
  • The Sense of WonderRachel Carson
  • freeGreater Good Science Center

do

The awe walk, weekly: go somewhere on foot with the explicit intention of noticing something vast, and no other agenda.

done when you have been stopped by something ordinary.

Traps

  • ·Art as content to be covered. A list of great novels read is not this page.
  • ·Explaining beauty to death. Meter and physics are elsewhere; the Dionysian is the point here.
  • ·Awe as a wellness hack. It doesn't survive being instrumentalised.